EXPLAINER: What Elon Musk’s dance with Twitter really means | National News

PROVIDENCE, R.I. (AP) — Tesla CEO Elon Musk’s wonderful Twitter turnabout — in which he disclosed his enormous stake in the social media enterprise, acquired a seat on its board, publicly floated drastic variations and then turned down the board position — all occurred in a week.

But its aftermath could linger if the mercurial billionaire who now holds a approximately 9% stake in Twitter proceeds to press forward his concepts for reshaping the small business of social media.

WHY Failed to MUSK Be a part of THE BOARD?

Musk said he knowledgeable Twitter on Saturday that he wouldn’t be signing up for its board of administrators, right after being invited five days previously, in accordance to a monetary disclosure. He did not explain why but the Saturday choice coincided with a barrage of now-deleted tweets from Musk proposing big modifications to the company, these kinds of as dropping ads — its main supply of income — and transforming its San Francisco headquarters into a homeless shelter. Musk left a couple clues on Twitter about his wondering, these types of as by “liking” a tweet that summarized the occasions as Musk heading from “largest shareholder for Cost-free Speech” to becoming “told to participate in nice and not communicate freely.”

Folks are also reading…

  • President Biden will visit Greensboro Thursday. This is what we know so considerably.
  • ‘Andy Griffith Show’ alum Ron Howard praises NC Outer Banks following ‘family adventure’
  • Child, 3, killed when latest sweeps her more than 400-foot NC waterfall
  • Two injured in capturing in the vicinity of Greensboro nightspot
  • ‘Lucky lady’: Greensboro councilwoman Abuzuaiter recounts brush with demise
  • A Greensboro health practitioner, again from Ukraine border, wishes he ‘could have accomplished more’
  • Dobson person dies in Greensboro crash, police say
  • Capturing at rapper DaBaby’s household in Troutman leaves 1 individual injured, Iredell County officers say
  • UPDATE: Biden finishes stop by to A&T and Greensboro, heads for airport
  • State wellbeing officers report maximize in new COVID-19 cases
  • Greensboro smoke store robbed
  • Substantial terrific white shark was lurking off North Carolina coastline, tracking shows
  • Center College or university at N.C. A&T renamed for A&T 4 to honor sit-in movement
  • Frost-bitten primates at NC animal farm dropped strategies of their tails, lemur’s hand hurt, USDA report claims
  • Greensboro rabbi ‘bears witness’ in Ukraine in a contemporary-working day Passover story

Twitter CEO Parag Agrawal reported Musk’s not becoming a member of was “for the best” but didn’t give specific explanations in a statement Monday. Agrawal also remaining some clues, noting that Musk had been awaiting a history examine and suggesting that Twitter required him on the board — rather than just as a major shareholder — mainly because as a fiduciary he’d be legally and ethically certain to act “in the very best interests of the enterprise and all of our shareholders.”


Musk has been tweeting for a extended time, but he started buying Twitter stock in earnest only a number of months in the past. He began on Jan. 31, when he acquired a tiny much more than 620,000 shares at $36.83 apiece. On virtually each individual solitary trading working day from then by way of April 1, he purchased hundreds of hundreds or hundreds of thousands additional of shares.

Entirely, Musk was in command of 73.1 million Twitter shares as of the most current depend, or 9.1% of the company. He invested $2.64 billion buying them all on the open up market. The marketplace price for all of Twitter, which include Musk’s stake, is roughly $38 billion.

HOW Major IS MUSK’S STAKE When compared WITH Some others?

Musk seemed to be Twitter’s most significant shareholder right up until financial investment big Vanguard Team filed a report late past 7 days showing it had supplanted him.

Vanguard controls 10.3% of the organization by way of investments made by its suite of mutual resources and ETFs. Vanguard and other fund giants are normally the most significant buyers in any business, as cash keeps pouring into their index resources from retirement savers and other traders. But these fund giants are usually considerably far more fingers-off as owners than activist traders, who can thrust for new management teams or big modifications in tactic.


Experienced Musk joined the board, he’d have been only one of quite a few voices in strategy conversations. And he may possibly have chafed at not being capable to order the organization around.

“The responsibility of the board of directors is to depict the shareholders,” explained Harry Kraemer, medical professor at Northwestern University’s Kellogg Faculty of Management and former chairman and CEO of Baxter International. “They’re not there to characterize by themselves.”

By turning down a seat on Twitter’s board, Musk also receives out of a guarantee to preserve his possession stake of Twitter at 14.9% or down below. No cost of that cap, he has the alternative to construct a even larger stake, where he could try to take more than the organization or enable elect a slate of administrators much more aligned with his considering.

“That 15% is an arbitrary number,” said Kraemer. “It’s not like if you own 15%, you can or just cannot do a little something else. I’m speculating, but probably the imagined was: If we bring him on as a director, and he just cannot get much more than 15%, that literally stops him from using handle of the corporation.”


When Musk initially unveiled his Twitter stake as a result of a submitting with the U.S. Securities and Trade Fee, he did it with a variety of type usually utilised by traders who really do not prepare to push for massive improvements at a firm. But he has given that amended that filing to use a broader form of form, a single that does not have the very same constraints.


He said in a filing with regulators on Monday that he owns the shares for “investment purposes.” He stated he might invest in a lot more, promote or just keep the shares, dependent on what happens with its rate and other factors.

He also reported that he may possibly chat with Twitter’s board and its administration group from time to time about method, as effectively as doable mergers, sales or acquisitions, among other points. The broadly followed tweeter was absolutely sure to take note that he may perhaps categorical his sights to the enterprise “through social media or other channels.”

Musk mentioned he has “no present designs or intentions,” but that his options could modify at any time.


Significantly of Musk’s vocal criticism of Twitter about modern weeks has centered all around his belief that it falls small on free of charge speech principles. The social media platform has angered followers of Donald Trump and other far-ideal political figures who’ve had their accounts suspended for violating its written content specifications on violence, detest or unsafe misinformation. Musk also has a record of his very own tweets creating legal difficulties.

But as lengthy as his attention is sustained, it can be not likely that Musk would make these types of a large play for Twitter if he didn’t also have strategic company interests, stated Enrique Abeyta, a former hedge fund supervisor and editor of Empire Money Exploration. It can be just about not possible to get started a new social media system, so Twitter provides the electronic equivalent of prime beachfront serious estate that just requires some tinkering and fresh thoughts, which could vary from using it personal to shifting to a membership-based mostly design with less speech limitations, Abeyta claimed.

“He plainly has demonstrated an curiosity in combining his philosophical beliefs and passions with his financial ones,” he reported. “I assume it would be incredibly risky to lower price him.”


Probably not. Neither Musk — who already serves as CEO of Tesla and SpaceX and has dabbled in a selection of other technological know-how ventures — nor most investors are likely to assume that’s a great strategy.

“He’d fairly be the chairman, the spirit animal, the male who saved Twitter and also produced $10 billion on it,” Abeyta claimed. “He’s the richest man or woman in the planet. Getting CEO sucks.”

Choe reported from New York.

Copyright 2022 The Affiliated Press. All legal rights reserved. This product might not be posted, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed with no permission.